Wednesday, April 4, 2007

Aborting the "Pro's"

Abortion is one of the most divisive issues in American politics. The subjects of an individual's right to choose and an unborn child's right to live are certainly hot-button issues, but by focusing strictly on Roe v. Wade and the bumper-sticker soundbytes our politicians offer, we are forgetting that there is much more to the issue than just "Pro-Life" or "Pro-Choice."

Like so many other issues in American politics, abortion has become a rallying cry for parties and candidates. Alan Keyes has made a career out of his stance on the issue. Religion and loyalty to God are often brought into the discussion. Extremists on both sides have gone too far, with some pro-life fanatics bombing clinics and some pro-choice supporters claiming that late-pregnancy terminations--where the baby could survive outside of the womb--should be legal. The vicious attacks on both sides have turned the issue into an argument.

What if we shifted the conversation to another part of the issue?

Abortion is a women's issue because the actual process concerns women. But it also has a great deal to do with men, because without men, there would be no pregnancy. Furthermore, the issue of the sanctity and value of life concerns all of us. But in the mission of both sides to see abortion rights either eliminated or expanded, the role of men in the issue has been greatly diminished.

The real problem is the growth of unwanted pregnancy in this country. Almost no one would say that abortion, in and of itself, is a good thing. No matter which side of the issue you fall on, putting a woman through that experience is not something to be proud of and taking a life--whether it is considered a fetus or an unborn child--is not something to be taken lightly. Of the several women I know who have had abortions and discussed it with me, none have expressed any joy in the event or its aftermath.

I am going to lay a few things on the table that may seem to upset some people, but it is in the spirit of progress and honest conversation that I do so.

At the root of this issue is a woman's desire to have consequence-free sex--to know that regardless of the outcome of intercourse, she will not have to bear a child. And why shouldn't women want this? Don't men have the privilege of knowing that they will not have to carry a child?

This is the concept I would like to challenge. I believe that if we hold the men in this country responsible for their actions, unwanted pregnancies will decline considerably. As it stands now, men not only have the luxury of knowing they will not have to carry a child, but also that they will not have to deal with having an abortion. For irresponsible men everywhere, abortion is a safety net. If their partner becomes pregnant, they can say they do not want the baby and that she should have an abortion. Even if the woman does not want to terminate the pregnancy, the man has absolved himself (in his mind) from any responsibility by saying that if it were his decision, he would end the pregnancy.

Many women choose to have the baby, even in extreme circumstances. There is an undeniable emotional connection between mother and child, and this exists even before birth. Abortion is not an easy choice. But for men, it is much simpler to say, "I don't want to have anything to do with that baby," and just run from the issue.

A policy that takes a two-pronged approach to resolving this disparity is in order. First, we need a law that makes men financially responsible for the pregnancy. Even if the pregnancy is unwanted, men cannot deny that they had no choice in the matter (unless there is a case of rape or deception). By engaging in sexual intercourse, you are participating in an activity where nature's intended outcome is reproduction. Many men will cry wolf, saying that they used contraception and it is not their fault, but they cannot escape the fact that they chose to have sex and that includes the possibility--no matter what birth control device is used--of pregnancy. For this reason, men can and should be held responsible for their actions, and should be held financially responsible for supporting the pregnancy (yes, that means supporting the woman carrying the child) and the baby.

The second piece of the puzzle is time. Women not only have to sacrifice time during the pregnancy (especially in the final month), but obviously once a child is born there is whole new level of responsibility. Men can never be held to the same standard, but the law can help equalize the situation. Fathers should be held responsible--by law and with the threat of imprisonment--for a certain number of care hours once a child is born.

Men denying responsibility for pregnancies would be submitted to paternity testing. If there is a positive match, then the law becomes effective and the financial and time responsibilities kick-in. Now you have a situation where both parties--men and women--must carefully consider the ramifications of intercourse. Young couples who have not thought things through will be put in tough circumstances where both partners' lives are forever altered by pregnancies.

Men will never be held to the same standard as women on this issue, because they cannot carry children. But the law can demand a more equal commitment. It is time we forced the men in this country to take this issue more seriously.

Tuesday, April 3, 2007

Government Savings

This is the final entry in the series exploring improvements to the federal tax system.

As noted in the previous entry, it is always important to consider the reason for taxes. Unless the goal is continue our movement towards a quasi-socialist European model (which would require rewriting the Constitution), the motive behind taxation must be reexamined.

Income tax is a relatively new concept. While it was implemented for a brief period during the civil war, the federal income tax did not become permanent until the 20th century. As America grew, so did the needs of her government, and the introduction of the tax to build a stout military and continue upgrading infrastructure was probably a good idea. But somewhere along the way, taxes became an excuse for government to overspend.

Each of the policies laid out in the previous entries on taxation include very specific goals. The flat income tax is earmarked primarily for military, education, and infrastructure needs. The charity tax puts money in the hands of difference-makers and encourages Americans to take care of one another. The incentive tax encourages responsible business practices. Cutting capital gains encourages saving and investing. And other policies, such as a charity tax on estates, would discourage inherited wealth and push each generation to make its mark.

What are the roots of our current system? How did over-taxation and overspending take hold in America?

During the Great Depression, FDR implemented a series of government-inflating policies called "The New Deal." Designed to save the U.S. economy from further disaster, a whole new batch of regulatory agencies were introduced. The goal of these new policies and bureaucracies was to provide relief, recovery, and reform.

This was a critical moment in our nation's history. FDR's presidency redefined the parties, turning the Democratic Party into a pro-government, neo-socialist reform party and transforming the Republican Party into a conservative watch-dog focused on a strong dollar, sturdy economy, and a balanced budget. Interestingly enough, these issues used to be the backbone of the democrats.

The proof of this change is found in an address FDR gave while he was the governor of New York. It demonstrates that FDR was not an idealist or a constitutionalist, but rather a pragmatist. Once in office, he changed his viewpoints entirely in a desperate attempt to save America from an economic wasteland. Here is the link to the address: http://www.lexrex.com/enlightened/writings/fdr_address.htm

The goal of the programs was to restore hope and prosperity to Americans, and FDR is widely credited with achieving this vision. I believe that he did, in some measure, boost the spirit of Americans enough to help them pick themselves up and start to rebuild our nation. Remember, the Great Depression saw unemployment as high as 25%--just a few years ago Bush was ripped for having a rate just above 6%.

The Supreme Court struck down several provisions of the New Deal, using judicial review to enforce the Constitution. The court believed that FDR's new agencies had gone well beyond the scope of the federal government's rights. The shear volume of programs, however, and their rising popularity, forced the court to abandon their strict judicial review by the time the second "New Deal" laws were enacted, and the federal government had begun its metamorphosis into the juggernaut it has become.

FDR was a great leader, and did help restore hope. But unemployment did not drop below 8% until 1942, when the U.S. had jumped into World War II. So the effectiveness of his policies--which were implemented in the early 1930's, must be questioned. While they had a great psychological effect on the American people, they failed to achieve their outright economic goals.

Unfortunately, the bureaucrats saw their opportunity to take hold of the government. Using FDR's popularity as a President (which had grown largely because of his success in WWII), politicians called for the continuance of many programs that seemed to contradict the grass roots principles FDR spoke about in 1930 when he was still the governor of New York. The result was and is a mass of self-perpetuating agencies that suck funding and produce little. LBJ took these ideas of mass bureaucracy and applied them to social issues, and by the end of his presidency we were doomed to our current situation: well over 60% of government spending is wrapped-up in inflexible, permanent programs and agencies. Sadly, no matter who takes office in 2008, things are likely to get worse, as these programs continue to grow despite their record of failure.

The irony in all this is that FDR knew, in 1930, that America would be headed for the quagmire we find ourselves in unless the federal government's growth was curbed.

The point is that spending begets spending, and taxing begets taxing, unless these policies has specific reform goals. FDR needed to give people hope, and the "New Deal" may have accomplished that, but most of its entangling laws should have been stricken down after World War II, when balance had been restored to the American economy. Instead, the unnecessary programs burgeoned, and LBJ tacked-on a litany of social policies that further bloated the government.

A key component in any tax plan must be to balance the budget and pay down the debt. Laws, and perhaps even an amendment to the Constitution, are required to achieve this goal. Extra dollars are not an excuse to start more programs. The government should have a surplus of funds available for emergencies--such as the Great Depression--to provide TEMPORARY relief. We must force our government to exercise fiscal restraint and repay the debt.

Let's turn that 60%-plus figure around. Let's come together and strike down the under-performing, over-spending programs, and allow the government to have control over 60-plus% of their funds instead just the the leftovers. Let's pay down the debt and build a surplus for emergencies. Taxes are not an excuse to spend. This is the honest change we need.

Monday, April 2, 2007

Business Class

This entry continues the series exploring improvements to the federal tax system.

Taxing business is a tricky issue. In our quasi-capitalist economy, businesses look at taxes the way they look at any other expense. What this means is that the cost of taxes is passed along to consumers in the form of higher prices and passed along to employees in the form of lower wages. So before issuing taxes on business, it is important for government to consider the goal of the taxes. If generating more tax revenue is the goal, then taxing business can often result in simply passing a larger tax burden onto the citizens.

There are other goals, however, that do justify taxing businesses. While payroll taxes are a bad idea--they just decrease wages for workers--other types of taxation can be used to encourage businesses to behave responsibly.

In a market economy, it is vital for large businesses to achieve results. Turning a profit increases the price of shares for a company, and this leads to more growth. Success begets success. For this reason, it is essential that businesses keep their expenses as low as possible, whatever those expenses may be.

A small tax of 8% on a company's cash flow would be the basis of the "Incentive Tax." The goal of this levy would be to encourage businesses to behave more responsibly.

It is important to note that this tax is on a company's cash flow, and not its net profit. Many businesses maintain positive cash flow and report a loss to the IRS. The incentive tax could not be side-stepped this way.

The incentive tax would decrease for every benchmark a business met. For example, an environmentally responsible business might see a 3% drop in the incentive tax rate. A business that stayed out of the court system (which is a big expense for taxpayers) could receive a 2% reduction, and so on.

The effect of this tax would be to push CEOs, CFOs, and boards of directors to meet these standards and avoid paying the tax. The outcome would be an immediate profit increase, leading to a rise in share prices. The market would demand that incentives were met.

One of the most important guidelines in an incentive tax would be the "Fair Pay" benchmark. A huge problem we face in our country today is the rise in household income for the top 20% of earners and relatively stagnant income growth for everyone else. The widening gap between the rich and the poor not only threatens productivity and long-term growth, it is also wiping out the middle class.

What is causing the problem? The overvaluing of executives has driven compensation packages for top-tier employees through the roof. While the market is dictating these astoundingly high pay increases, it is ignoring the overall effect on the work force and the future of our economy.

Let me offer an example. A friend of mine works in sales for a large energy broker. Recently he was working on a huge project, and partnered with an independent consultant. After two years of research, negotiation, and hard work, they closed a deal worth almost $7 million that would turn an enormous profit. The consultant--who did no more or less than my friend--received a check for well over $700,000. What was the reward for my friend? A $500 gift certificate to the local country club. One man receives a check that could fund his retirement, while the other gets a few rounds of golf.

It is hard to blame the decision-makers for these unbalanced policies--our short-sighted market economy dictates that businesses are required to produce higher profits now, not in five years. But because this attitude has taken hold in corporate America, the average worker has been short-changed. Productivity is dropping while hours increase. The incentive for the average worker to excel is decreasing. While inflation continues to rise as CEOs spend their bloated paychecks, the workforce becomes less and less inspired to succeed.

This must stop. Promotion from within must increase, and workers need to be rewarded for exceptional service to a company. Since the market is failing to establish this itself, the Incentive Tax would force a board of directors to choose between hiring a big-name CEO (to make a splash in the market), resulting in an immediate reduction in cash flow from the Incentive Tax, or promoting from within to improve worker morale and save 3% annually. An incentive that promoted higher pay for better performance at all levels of a company would work wonders for America and would help restore a middle class.

The bulk of the revenue generated by the incentive tax would be used for government to maintain standards of honesty and integrity in business. Corporations choosing to side-step ethics and walk the thin line of the law would face constant government oversight, while companies committed to honest practices that benefit everyone (not just the board of directors) would pay less in taxes and operate more freely.

White collar crime penalties would increase. More prison time and higher fines would result from dishonest business practices. A focus on punishing the individual, rather than the company, would be the backbone of the policy. Capitalism cannot excel without honesty.

Good behavior needs to be rewarded. Bad behavior needs to be discouraged. America needs to get back to building stronger, smarter, more loyal, long-term thinking corporations. Taxes on business should encourage this, instead of just passing higher costs along to consumers.

Friday, March 30, 2007

Giving Results

This entry continues the series exploring improvements to the federal tax system.

It is clear that the ideas presented in the previous entries will require huge cuts in government spending. Many people, including government employees, have become dependent on these programs, and cutting them will certainly put some Americans in a difficult position.

Fortunately, there is a community in America that is dedicated to helping people in need, and, unlike the government, they achieve consistent results.

I'm talking about our charitable institutions. Americans give huge dollar amounts to charity every year, and these smart, competitive organizations stretch the contributions they receive to the limit. How do I know? I spent two years working as the Director of Development (fundraising manager) of a non-profit charity.

Charities do not work like government. They understand how difficult it is for people to give and appreciate every dollar they receive. Donors are an intelligent group as well, only contributing to the best-run charities that produce consistent results. In short, the charitable giving industry has a client/company relationship that closely resembles that of businesses. In the case of non-profits, the product you are offering a donor is the fulfillment of their desire to help others and improve their communities, their country, and the world. Producing better results and making donations go further naturally leads to receiving more donations, just like an effectively run business that satisfies its clients tends to do more business.

This is a distinctly different model from government entitlement programs. Rather than investigating best practices and thoroughly examining each case, government gives money on the basis of predetermined benchmarks. What this means is that if an individual meets the qualifications laid out in the law, he or she is entitled to receive benefits. Furthermore, government does not have a responsibility to its donors, because taxpayers must fund the government. By its very nature, it is an inefficient institution. The result is poorly run programs that fail to produce results.

I have also worked at a homeless shelter. During my time there, dozens of homeless individuals came into the shelter to take advantage of its functions, which included a place to shower, free meals, reception services (yes, we even received mail and took phone messages for homeless individuals), public transportation fare, food stamps, and benefit applications.

At the risk of sounding callous, I was amazed at how few of these homeless individuals were taking active steps to find gainful employment or housing. My second day there, I approached a woman who had been working there for several years and asked her about this. She explained that about 1-in-30 people coming through their doors were making use of the intended function of the shelter, which was to help these individuals get back to work and find homes. My experience at the shelter confirmed her estimation.

This is not efficient. The cost of running the shelter must have been extremely high. There were at least five full-time employees in a large office space in an area where real estate prices are among the highest per square foot in the nation. The food and bus tokens alone must have totaled at least $1000 per day. No charity in the country could operate so poorly (a 1-in-30 success rate) and continue to receive donations.

Contrast this performance with that of "Habitat for Humanity," a well-known charity committed to building shelter for those in need. This organization has constructed over 200,000 homes and shelters, and finishes a new shelter every 24 minutes. Every 24 minutes! By June of 2006, Habitat had put 100 families who had been devastated by Hurricane Katrina into new homes. By mid-summer of 2007, they project that 1,000 new residences will have been constructed for the hurricane victims. And these are not shacks or government projects, either. I encourage readers to visit their website, www.habitat.org, and see what real charity looks like.

And that's not all. Habitat also does vast amounts of work abroad. Over the next 18 months, they expect to build 10,000 homes for victims of the Indian Ocean tsunami. Not only does this save lives and help people start over, it also aids in improving the image of the United States around the world.

Like all charitable organizations, Habitat publishes an annual report that the public can read (this is where all this information comes from). All non-profits are transparent, allowing potential donors to see the organization's record of success. The government frequently fails to research the success of its own programs, much less offering the public an opportunity to look at its records and determine whether or not they wish to continue funding the waste.

Because a charity's income is tied to its performance, efficiency and effectiveness are vital to operations. Because the government's income is guaranteed, efficiency and effectiveness are almost unnecessary.

On top of the 20% income tax proposed in previous entries, Americans should be asked to give to charity. Requiring this by law would flood money into our charitable organizations, and this is sure to be more effective than any government program. A sliding scale based on total income level would look like this:

Income (in thousands of dollars); (Percentage Tax)
$25-50 (5%)
50-75 (6%)
75-100 (7%)
100-200 (8%)
200+ (10%)

This scale does not mean that an individual making $250,000 per year must give $25,000 (10%) to charity. What it means is that the first $25K of income is charity tax free, the next $25K is taxed at 5% (for a total of $1250), the next $25K at 6% ($1500), and so on. So, using the above example, an individual earning $250K would pay a total of $17,500 ($1250 + 1500 + 1750 + 8000 + 5000) in charity tax. That amounts to only 7% of the $250K in total income.

Along with the new charity tax, fierce penalties for charity fraud would be written into law. Individuals who are caught trying to beat the system would be fined and jailed.

The end result would be amazing. Not only would charities help the Americans who need help, but instead of a government program throwing money at a problem it will be Americans helping Americans (and foreigners). Anyone who has ever been involved in charity work knows what a special relationship this is, and how beneficial it is for all parties involved.

The influx of funding to charities would also boost the industry, opening new possibilities for philanthropy and allowing anyone with a good idea on how to help people make it a reality. Charities would continue to strive for excellence and compete for dollars, and Americans could choose how their contribution improved their community, country, or the world.

American taxpayers deserve a good return on their investment. Let charities and fellow Americans take care of each other, and let the government take care of funding things like infrastructure, military and security, and public education. This is the kind of honest change we need.

Thursday, March 29, 2007

Investing Incentive

This entry continues the series exploring improvements to the federal tax system.

Reading the ideas on tax reform in the previous might have accountants and tax attorneys crying "foul." But there is no cause for concern.

The government has done some things well when it comes to the tax code. Because the wealthy financial sector has so much pull in Washington, several good ideas have made their way into the tax code regarding passive and portfolio income. These incentives encourage Americans to invest in certain ventures that would otherwise be too risky or unprofitable. Depreciation, depletion, intangible drilling costs, IRAs, Keogh Plans, TICs--there is a vast list of investment activities and incentives that avoid absurd taxation.

The problem is that most Americans cannot afford and/or do not understand the benefits of these investments. Having a "money" curriculum in our public schools, beginning in elementary school and lasting through high school, will help our citizens understand the advantages and importance of saving and investing. But what about the cost?

As it stands now, the average American pays so much in fees and taxes that investing--while still crucial to one's financial well-being and retirement--does not feel like it is worth the effort. Furthermore, those who do invest regularly tend to do so in very limited ways and for very specific things, such as retirement accounts, college funds, or saving for a down payment on a home. Very few Americans have a steady stream of passive income. This needs to change.

One of the keys to having more time to spend with family and take care of the most important things in life is having the financial resources to do so. As is demonstrated in recent books such as "The Two Income Trap," our current system makes it very difficult to live in a good neighborhood with decent schools unless both parents have a job. Combine this fact with the shorter vacations and longer hours our country works, and there is little time left for family.

A great way to start fixing this problem is to make the first $25,000 of passive and portfolio income tax free. This means that a couple could earn up to $50,000 in passive income without paying a penny in taxes. Maintaining current tax incentive laws along with this new deduction would result in an explosion of investment by Americans, and would create a whole new investment industry for the low-income investor.

Taking this a step further, the capital gains tax would be reduced to a 10% for short-term (12 month) and 5% for long-term (more than 1 year). Again, no taxes would be paid until that $25K threshold is exceeded. Passive income would be taxed at the 20% flat rate, but the $25K tax-free rule would be combined with all the current deductions for passive income, making it easy to earn extremely high returns while paying little or nothing in taxes. These new policies would allow Americans earning a modest income to start putting their money to work instead of working so hard for their money.

The economic benefits of this plan would be extensive. More investing would allow companies to be more creative and take more risks. Finding the necessary funding to translate good ideas into profitable ventures would be easier. Middle and lower-middle class Americans could generate helpful, steady streams of income. The market surges would bring in vast amounts of foreign capital, strengthening the dollar and keeping more and better jobs in the United States. And, after a few years of lean tax revenues, the growth in the economy would actually create a surplus and allow us to pay down the national debt.

We need to become a country of long-term thinkers. In today's market economy, long-term thinking also brings about short-term results. How? Making investing more attractive will flood money into the markets, giving companies more money to hire and pay workers, research new technologies to create new jobs and new industries, and boosting profit-sharing. If we educate our citizens properly and "incentivize" investing, Americans will learn to leverage their individual capital for gain while at the same time pouring money into the companies and entrepreneurs that keep America's economy ahead of its competitors.

The flip-side of this policy is disastrous. If we continue to make investing so complicated and expensive--keeping it out of the reach of middle-class America--we are in danger of losing our status as the world's preeminent economic power and losing our valuable technology and financial sector jobs to foreign markets.

So why haven't we done this yet? Because elections are based largely on unemployment rates, and incumbent politicians know they can earn votes by mortgaging our future to create temporary, superficial job-growth. Also, the wealthy financial sector, lobbyists, lawyers, and politicians already know the loopholes of the system, so there is no need for them to change it--even though these proposed changes would benefit them as well.

Let's learn to think long-term and support honest change in our tax system.

Wednesday, March 28, 2007

Tax Returns

This entry continues the series exploring improvements to the federal tax system.

Taxes themselves are not the problem. When the colonists revolted against the British Empire, they were not opposed to the idea of paying taxes. They were opposed to the idea of paying taxes without getting anything in return.

Americans have always been relatively smart with their money. This is because we live in a quasi-capitalist society that rewards hard work and entrepreneurship. I do not believe the frustrations many feel about taxes are simply because we do not want to pay taxes. I think Americans see the value in things like a strong military, public education, and infrastructure.

The real problem is that we are not getting a good return on our investment.

Despite the huge amounts of money flowing into the federal government, our education system is a mess, we have too many extraneous laws and government institutions, and we have a tax code that is overly-complicated and unfair.

Instead of squabbling over tax-bracket percentages, marriage penalties or deductions, and the moratorium on the estate tax, we need to shift the conversation to wholesale reform of the tax code.

I heard a great interview with a U.S. Postal Service worker on the radio the other day. He was explaining why the price of stamps is increasing again. "We have too many supervisors," he said. "There are too many people who are not doing anything and are getting paid."

Government institutions have the luxury of knowing that they have no competition. The USPS (United States Postal Service) will exist for as long as the laws of the nation support its existence, regardless of how poorly it is run. Inefficiency is actually rewarded, because in most government programs, your budget is based on how much you spend. This means that finishing the year under budget often means that your budget is cut. Conversely, a government organization that consistently fails to meet budget expectations will retain a high budget or even win a budget increase.

Does this sound like an efficient system? No wonder Americans do not feel like they are getting a good return on their investment in the federal government.

The solution is clear. If we lower tax rates to a reasonable level for all of our citizens, we will see long-term growth, and force government to cut its waste. Over the period of a decade, federal tax revenue will actually increase, allowing the government pay down our ridiculous national debt, which is now at about $8.85 trillion and continues to balloon.

As it currently stands, the tax system's loopholes allow two individuals with the same income to pay substantially different amounts in taxes. This is not fair, and I believe it is unconstitutional. Why? Because our freedom to spend our money as we choose is one of our basic rights as Americans. If John and Sally both make $100, and Sally has to pay $30 in taxes while John's creative accountant structures his finances so that he only has to pay $5 in taxes, this is unfair.

All human beings require the three basic needs: food, clothing, and shelter. We can assume that a portion of everyone's income goes to fulfilling these needs. The remainder of income is left to spend on choices--things like recreation, investments, charity, or upgrades to the basic needs. Because John and Sally live in the same country under the same laws, we will also assume that they receive the same freedoms and protections from these laws. Taking more from Sally in taxes, however, eliminates a higher percentage of her income, leaving her with a much more limited opportunity to make choices. This is, in essence, taking more of her freedom.

We need a simple tax system that takes 20% of active income from every citizen. No more deductions, penalties, or credits. Every American knows that $1 out of every $5 they earn is going to the federal government, and must budget accordingly.

Taking this a step further, the first $25,000 of income is not taxed. This means that when you receive your paycheck--if your salary is $25K or less--no taxes are withheld. The process of paying taxes only so that the government can return them to you is inefficient. Individuals making more than $25K could choose to amortize their payments over the course of the year or to begin paying 20% after they have earned their first $25K.

Think about how easy it would be to prepare a tax return. No deductions, no filing jointly, no dependents, no credits, no penalties--no loopholes. Everyone pays 20% of their active income over $25,000.

Imagine the one page, ten minute tax form that you could fill out during a coffee break. Instead of sending the government money at the end of the tax year or getting a refund, each citizen simply pays as they go. While it feels good to receive a refund at the end of the year, the fact is that all you are getting is money that was yours to begin with. This means that the government was holding your money all year. Banks have to pay interest to do that. Conversely, when individuals underpay, they are withholding money from the government. All of this breeds inefficiency and requires a larger IRS, opening the door for more mistakes, more loopholes, and more wasted money.

Let's stop squabbling over tax reform and demand an entirely new policy.

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Failure to Comply

This entry continues the series exploring ideas for improvements to our federal tax system.

The previous entry touched on the immensity of the federal tax code. That it was 16,485 pages in March of 2006 (by now it is longer) is astonishing in and of itself, but it is not just its length that makes it so ridiculous.

The complexity of the code is the real issue. As noted in the previous entry, Americans spend $265 billion on compliance costs in 2005. Federal tax revenue was around $1.2 trillion. That means that 22% extra was spent on complying with the tax code. So the real cost of taxes is much higher than the number on a tax return.

It is not just business paying for the absurdly high compliance costs. As consumers and employees, businesses pass expenses along to us anyway--but individuals totaled 44% of the $265 billion spent on compliance in 2005. Stack on top of that an average of 25 hours spent working on compliance, and it is easy to see that the government should actually be paying us to determine what it costs to pay our taxes.

And it is not just inefficient for the taxpayers. The government wastes vast amounts of time and resources on compliance. But because tax codes are so complex and so vast, even Uncle Sam has a hard time getting it right.

Here's a true story to support my case. While it concerns state taxes, it demonstrates the absurdity of our tax laws. Last year, after sending my state tax return, I received a letter indicating that I owed another $42 in taxes. There was no explanation for this assessment, just a dollar figure and a date. Since I do my own taxes, I went back and reviewed my information, and checked it again with the tax software I used to compute taxes. According to my hand calculation and the software, I had paid the correct amount.

I decided to send a letter explaining why I believed I did not owe another $42 in taxes, and included copies of my federal and state returns. Several weeks later, I received another bill, this time for $43.71, because I now owed interest on my late payment. Thinking it best to cut my losses and pay the state, I sent my check for the full amount.

Two weeks later, the state must have finally figured out that my calculations were correct, because they sent me a check back for just over $44--the amount I paid plus the interest they owed me.

I would like to think that this is rare occurrence, but because my tax return was relatively uncomplicated, the only logical conclusion is that these things happen frequently.

So who benefits from this mess of a tax code? The wealthy lawyers and accountants who earn their living helping the rest of us comply with the system. Furthermore, the wealthiest Americans are able to take advantage of all the loopholes and end-up paying a lower percentage than middle-class Americans.

This must stop. Two people with the same income should pay the same in taxes. It should not be the better accountant or lawyer who determines what we owe the government. In this age of instant information, we ought to be able to look at a simple form a the end of the year, sign our name, and write our check or receive or refund. There should not be 40-plus page tax returns, forms with more abbreviations than anyone can remember, or huge governmental organizations spending millions of tax dollars on trying to figure out if each citizen is actually paying what they owe.

It is time to streamline the system and the process. The government benefits from the mystery of the tax code--most of us do not realize how or how much we actually pay--and it allows them to perpetuate the failing programs and offices that put more dollars into politicians' pockets.

Americans deserve a tax code that is simple, fair, logical, and requires the government to demonstrate fiscal restraint.